Shopify vs. BigCommerce for Health & Beauty Brands: Which Platform is Right for You?

Having worked extensively with health and beauty brands—such as our successful collaboration with BrunoMD—I understand firsthand the unique demands these businesses have. Subscription models, product bundling, loyalty programs, and an intuitive user experience are essential for success in this competitive market. When evaluating Shopify and BigCommerce for health and beauty brands, it’s important to consider these factors closely. Let’s dive deep into how each platform performs in these critical areas, highlighting some real-world results from our projects.

Subscription Management

Subscription models are a cornerstone of success in the health and beauty sector, creating consistent revenue streams and fostering customer loyalty.

Shopify:

• Shopify has a strong ecosystem for subscriptions, primarily through third-party apps like Recharge, Bold Subscriptions, and PayWhirl. These apps are powerful and offer flexible subscription configurations.
• Shopify’s subscription apps integrate smoothly, making setup straightforward and ensuring an easy customer experience. In our BrunoMD project, using Recharge for subscriptions significantly streamlined subscription management, resulting in increased subscriber retention and boosted recurring revenue.

BigCommerce:

• BigCommerce also provides robust subscription functionality through apps like Recharge and Bold Subscriptions, similar to Shopify.
• The setup and ongoing management in BigCommerce are equally robust, though the Shopify ecosystem tends to have more extensive community support and app options.

User Experience and Design Flexibility

A polished, intuitive user experience and visual appeal are crucial, especially in health and beauty, where brand image significantly influences customer trust and buying decisions.

Shopify:

• Shopify shines brightly here, providing aesthetically pleasing themes that are ideal for beauty brands. The platform’s intuitive user experience helps brands easily highlight their products attractively.
• Using a headless Shopify architecture for BrunoMD allowed us to create a uniquely tailored frontend experience, dramatically improving site speed and overall user engagement.

BigCommerce:

• BigCommerce offers flexible, customizable themes as well, but out-of-the-box options generally require a bit more initial tweaking to achieve the highly polished look that health and beauty brands demand.
• While fully capable, it might take more upfront work to reach the same visual finesse provided effortlessly by Shopify.

Bundled Products & Promotions

Effective bundling strategies and promotional campaigns are pivotal for enhancing sales and customer value in health and beauty.

Shopify:

• Shopify’s extensive app marketplace provides numerous solutions for bundling products and creating targeted promotions easily. Apps like Bundle Builder and Bold Bundles make creating custom bundles straightforward and intuitive.
• My clients have found Shopify incredibly versatile for testing various promotions rapidly without extensive setup.

BigCommerce:

• BigCommerce natively supports advanced product bundling and promotional strategies, meaning you might not need as many third-party apps as with Shopify.
• It’s well-suited to businesses that prefer built-in solutions and might require fewer ongoing subscriptions or additional software.

Loyalty & Rewards Programs

Creating strong loyalty programs that reward repeat customers is essential in a market like health and beauty, where competition is intense and customer retention is crucial.

Shopify:

• Shopify’s extensive selection of loyalty apps like Smile.io, LoyaltyLion, and Yotpo Rewards makes creating and managing these programs simple.
• Integration with email marketing and social media is seamless, enabling personalized customer communications, significantly boosting retention.

BigCommerce:

• BigCommerce also integrates effectively with loyalty platforms like LoyaltyLion and Smile.io.
• The process of setting up and managing loyalty programs is smooth, though Shopify typically offers slightly broader options and integrations.

Scalability and Growth

Growth trajectory matters when choosing your platform. Scalability ensures that your initial choice won’t become a bottleneck as your brand expands.

Shopify:

• Shopify’s scalability is proven repeatedly, especially for rapidly growing health and beauty brands that start small and scale quickly.
• It’s particularly beneficial for brands heavily leveraging social commerce and influencer marketing.

BigCommerce:

• BigCommerce offers robust scalability, especially suitable for mid-sized to larger brands with more complex operational requirements.
• Its superior performance in handling large product catalogs and complex backend integrations makes it ideal for brands planning extensive expansion.

Backend Integrations & ERP Compatibility

Streamlining your operations with seamless backend integrations to ERPs and other essential business software is vital for health and beauty companies, particularly as they grow.

Shopify:

• Shopify’s API-first approach allows for extensive integrations but often requires middleware for more complex ERP setups.
• Ideal for brands comfortable using multiple apps or middleware solutions.

BigCommerce:

• BigCommerce provides strong built-in compatibility with major ERPs, including NetSuite, Acumatica, and Microsoft Dynamics, facilitating easier and more direct integrations.
• Recommended for businesses with significant operational complexity looking to minimize middleware reliance.

Recommended Choice by Business Size

Small to Mid-Size Health & Beauty Brands:

• Shopify: Ideal for brands emphasizing rapid market entry, seamless design, robust social integrations, and easy-to-manage subscriptions.

Mid-Size to Enterprise Health & Beauty Brands:

• BigCommerce: Preferable for brands seeking powerful built-in capabilities, sophisticated backend integrations, multi-store capabilities, and comprehensive subscription management.

Final Thoughts: Making Your Decision

Both Shopify and BigCommerce offer compelling, robust solutions for health and beauty brands. Your final choice depends heavily on your unique operational needs, growth trajectory, and long-term vision.

If you’re a smaller brand or startup, Shopify’s intuitive interface, ease of use, and extensive app ecosystem might be the better fit, helping you rapidly grow your subscription base and customer loyalty programs effortlessly.

Conversely, BigCommerce is optimal for larger, more complex operations requiring comprehensive backend integration, advanced product management, and built-in scalability from the start.

Considering a migration or starting fresh? Check out our detailed BrunoMD case study to learn more about our approach to building successful, scalable health and beauty online stores.

‍